Thursday, February 25, 2016

Three Choices of Political-Economic Philosophy in the US Presidential Election

There are a lot of confusing issues swirling around in the current presidential election: gay marriage, abortion, gun rights, immigration, police brutality, racism, women's rights, financial regulation, healthcare costs, foreign wars, social security, money in politics, climate change, etc. etc. All these issues (and new ones that will certainly be introduced to stir the debate) resolve into a choice of three political-economic philosophies. Understanding the philosophies can help you evaluate the political rhetoric and inform your voting.

The three political-economic philosophies that are being offered to US voters are:
If you understand these philosophies, make a decision about which one you support and place the candidates in the philosophy they support, your decisions will be a lot easier. First, follow the links above to understand the philosophies (if this is new territory) then use the following cheat sheet to classify candidates:


The Embedded Liberalism of the post-WWII era failed during the 1970's in the US after a period of stagflation. Neoliberalism ran from the 1980s until the Financial Crisis of 2008. Follow the graphs below to see why Neoliberalism began failing after 2008. The choices are to continue with a political-economic philosophy with this track record (a don't-kill-the-golden-goose strategy for some), re-ignite the Neoconservativism of the Bush II years that ended in Financial Crisis or return to Embedded Liberalism, possibly with some Social Democratic updates. 

These are the political-economic philosophies that seem to be in play in the current US presidential election. Inform yourself, understand the choices, locate confusing issues within the philosophies and it will be easier to motivate support of a candidate and voting. Think of the different philosophies as strategies that might, if pursued, either benefit or not benefit you, the US and the World (not necessarily all the same thing). Vote and support your political-economic interests. To me this is the essence of Democracy since we do not all have the same political-economic interests.

THE TRACK RECORD OF NEOLIBERALISM

Neoliberalism emerged in the 1980's and started failing after the Financial Crisis of 2008 as a result of internal contradictions (Harvey, 2005). Neoliberalism was originally sold on the basis of widely accepted economic theory, a theory used to advise governments on policy. In practice, Neoliberalism did not perform as predicted by it's theory.

The most important consequence of Neoliberalism in the US has been an increase in Income Inequality as measured by the GINI index, plotted in the graph below. Notice that income inequality in the US is approaching levels not seen since then end of the 1920s. During the 1980's, Neoliberalism was sold on the basis of trickle-down theory: policies that benefited the wealthy would benefit everyone. 


If you are a wealthy person or come from a wealthy family, then Neoliberalism has been a great success for you and you should be interested in seeing it continue. If not, your political-economic interests may be elsewhere.

Another chart that displays a similar historical pattern is the share of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) in the Financial Industry, a measure of Financialization (the dominance of US Finance Capital or the power of Wall Street). There are the familiar "twin peaks" in both the inequality and the financialization graphs: one just before the Great Depression and another right before the Financial Crisis of 2008. The important enabling legislation: regulation that separated investing from banking, passed after the Great Depression (the Glass-Stegall Act passed in 1933), was eventually repealed during the Clinton Administration in 1999, nine years before the Financial Crisis of 2008.


If you work in or derive your income from the Financial Sector or live off the earnings of a Trust Fund, it will probably be in your interest to see Neoliberalism continue. If your only contact with the US Financial sector is through high-interest credit card debt and poor returns on savings accounts, your political-economic philosophy might not align with Wall Street.

Just to make clear the importance of the last two graphs graphs and one to follow, in an economic system where growth is "balanced" (a balanced-growth equilibrium or balanced-growth path in Neoclassical Economics), all variables should grow at a constant rate. Unbalanced growth is considered a failure of the economic system typical in "undeveloped" economies. Any policy derived from Neoclassical Economics should not produce unbalanced growth.

A final example of unbalanced growth is the comparison of worker productivity to hourly compensation. The graph below shows that the two started to diverge in the 1970s, again the start of Neoliberalism in the US. Neoclassical Economics, the theoretical foundation of Neoliberalism taught in all major US universities, requires that wages keep pace with productivity, that is, workers should receive their marginal product. 


Other economic theories can be used to explain constant wages or hourly compensation (see the Dual-Sector model of Arthur Lewis or Paul Samuelson's Dissection of Marxian Economics) but Marxian economics is not widely embraced in either Academia or the US Government. Breaking Labor Unions and exporting jobs to low-wage peripheral countries was supposed to benefit workers through trickle-down theory. In practice, the theory was flawed.

Another key part of the Neoliberal philosophy was the placement of all social services in the free-market private sector where competition can supposedly control prices. The result of free-market forces in health care has, for example, been opposite what was predicted. The US saw a large increase in the price of medical care commodities after the Health Maintenance Organization Act of 1973 which was inspired by Neoliberal thinking. If you work in the health care industry and have benefited from these increases in prices charged to consumers, then you will want to see Neoliberalism continue. If you are a consumer of health care services and either have increasingly large co-payments or must pay out-of-pocket medical expenditures, you might favor a political-economic strategy other than Neoliberalism.



The result of market forces in higher education has been a steep increase in college tuition, again starting in the 1970s. If you work in higher education and have benefited from the increases in expenditures, then you would like to see Neoliberalism continue. If you are a college student, a family who wants to send their children to college or a lower ranking employee in Higher Education (non-star faculty and academic staff), you have not benefited from market forces in education and would probably prefer some political-economic philosophy other than Neoliberalism.



Finally, there has been an increase in gun ownership within the US. The trend started after 9/11 (the September 11 Terrorist Attacks on the World Trade Center) and was not a direct result of Neoliberalism. However, the personal freedom and responsibility emphasized by Neoliberalism looks at the trend positively. If you are a gun owner or are concerned about arming yourself defensively, you will probably find Neoconservativism attractive. If you are intimidated by armed citizens carrying loaded weapons in US streets and are inclined to favor gun control, then you will probably find Social Democracy more attractive.



The topic of gun ownership fits well with consideration of US military expenditures. The graph below shows that the US, by far, outspends the rest of the world on the military. It is a cost of being the hegemonic leader of the world system. If you think this level of expenditure is correct or should even be higher, you will be comfortable with Neoconservativism or Neoliberalism. If you think the expenditures are too high then you will probably favor Social Democracy. However, it is important to note that even during the period of Embedded Liberalism after WWII, a high level of military expenditure has always been part of US political culture. The question is whether that should change at this point in history.



EXERCISES

Where candidates fall on the three philosophies is somewhat difficult to determine. Especially if candidates are good politicians, they and their supporters will attempt to obscure their positions to gain votes. I have refrained from putting candidates in boxes for you. You will need to inform yourself on the political philosophies and do your best to make judgment calls. Here are some exercises that might help.
  1. Using web sites that compare candidates on various issues (here, here, here and here), try to identify the political-economic philosophies of each presidential candidate (use the table at the beginning of this post).
  2. Using candidate's own web sites (Bernie Sanders, Hillary Clinton, Donald Trump, Ted Cruz, Marco Rubio, Jeb Bush, etc.) and the party platforms (Republican Party, Democratic Party or a site that compares all party platforms here) test your understanding of their political-economic philosophies. Compare candidates to their parties.
  3. Evaluate past presidents and their administrations (Reagan, Carter, Bush I, Clinton, Bush II, and Obama administrations). How clear was their political-economic philosophy when they entered office? How did their political-economic philosophy change over time, if at all? How easy was it to predict their major decisions based on a political-economic philosophy?

Good luck!

Friday, November 20, 2015

Tuesday, August 11, 2015

The Most Interesting Man in the World

The Most Interesting Man in the World advertising campaign for Dos Equis (two X's) beer was one of my most favorite, funny and outrageous commercials. The bearded, debonair gentleman was played by actor Jonathan Goldsmith who himself had a very interesting career in film and advertising. The campaign lives on in Internet memes showing a photograph with some variant of the commercial "I don't always drink beer, but when I do I prefer Dos Equis." Since beer gives me migraines, my favorite variant on the theme is displayed above. Also, the tag at the end of the commercial was typically "Stay thirsty, my friends" which I have always assumed to be a play on Stay Hungry which is the only way I have ever been able to control my weight. The video below is a compilation of the commercials.

Tuesday, July 28, 2015

Definitely Miles


My second favorite Miami Vice episode, if there can be such a thing (my favorite is discussed here), was titled Junk Love and featured Miles Davis playing Ivory Jones, the desk clerk at a hotel for high-priced call girls. Miles makes his first appearance at the beginning of the episode and I can still remember almost falling off the sofa when I saw it. There's no mistaking it. That's definitely Miles Davis! And, if you aren't a Miles Davis fan, start by listening to the album Kind of Blue, the birth of cool Jazz.

Saturday, July 25, 2015

Definitely Miami Vice



Definitely Miami is by far my favorite Miami Vice TV episode. It's noteworthy for many reasons starting with the introduction, a long and slow camera shot set to Carlos Santana's beautiful Europa as played by Gato Barbieri  to the final scenes set to the hypnotic one-hit-wonder, Godley and Creme's Cry (considered one of the defining scenes of Miami Vice as a show). It's also notable for Casting Ted Nugent as serial killer Charlie Basset, from the time when Ted Nugent was still making music like Dog Eat Dog. Kick back, feel the heat (sorry about the commercials, kind of like seeing it on TV--buy the DVD).

Quotes:

Crockett: It's hot enough to fry an egg on my face.
Tubbs: Hope I never get that hungry.

Calle: Do you own this place.
Crockett: No, some people I work for own it and they let me use it whenever I want.
Calle: I could make you that deal.

Crockett: This is America. Cut yourself free. Find a new place. Get a job.
Calle: (Laughing) Men are my job... Not really men. One man. One man who will give me what I need. I'll do anything for him. Whatever he wants. Whatever he needs. Whatever he needs to want. Anything! Anything!
Crockett: You'd build your life around a man?
Calle: Yes!
Crockett: Does it matter which one?
Calle: But of course it matters, Sonny. It matters a lot.
Crockett: Does it matter enough to look before you leap? You don't know me. You don't know anything about me. You don't know what you're dealing with.
Calle: But of course I know you. I knew you from the very first minute I saw you. You're restless. You're hungry. You're lonely. You have dreams.

(They kiss).

Calle: Hold me tight. This may never happen again.

(Break for commercial).

From the standpoint of a single man (I was single when I first saw this episode), I can't say I've ever seen a more seductive scene on TV. Of course no woman could ever get away with this kind of dialog, but the fantasy factor is really high here and my mind is starting to get a little confused and not thinking very clearly. Maybe it's just the Miami heat. Oh yes, Calle is played by Arielle Dombasle.

Tuesday, June 9, 2015

I'll have what she's having -- Estelle Reiner.



The Delicatessen scene from When Harry Met Sally, playing now at our house. Best quotes:

Sally Albright: "You are a human affront to all women and I am a woman."

Sally Albright: "Oh. Right. That's right. I forgot. You're a man."

Older Woman Customer (Estelle Reiner): "I'll have what she's having" one of the most memorable funny lines in movie history according to the New York Times. The line was written by Billy Crystal. More great quotes from the movie here.

Written by Nora Ephron (1941-2012), directed by Rob Reiner, music by Marc Shaiman and Harry Connick, Jr. and with a great cast.